VG247.COM - http://www.vg247.com/2009/06/05/e3-2009-%E2%80%93-who-won-the-press-conferences/

MS 9/10
Sony 8/10
Nintendo 6/10

Update:

VG247.COM - Microsoft
GameSpot - Microsoft
GameTrailers - Sony
G4TV- Microsoft
GamePro - Microsoft

G4TV The Feed - http://www.vg247.com/2009/06/05/e3-2009-%E2%80%93-who-won-the-press-conferences/

MS B+
Sony B-
Nintendo C

GamePro - http://www.gamepro.com/article/features/210636/e3-2009-the-best-and-worst-of-e3/

MS A-
Nintendo C+
Sony B+

There is a pretty clear trend that puts Microsoft out in front.

That's two consecutive victories at E3 to the Redmond giant.

it was so clear, even fanboys accepted that...

Natal won most sites over I guess.

E3 is like the presidential election. They talk a lot, show 'screen shots' of how things 'will be'. They lie to you, but make it sound very believable. Then everyone is like 'Yay, company x won E3 because of the potential of what they said!'

The truth is, with E3 or the presidential election, no one really knows until well after it's over. Fortunately for games, if a once-thought winning company doesn't deliver, the other 2 are still there. With the president, if he doesn't deliver...I'd say we're fucked, but most of them never do and we're still alive for now..so hmm.

I don't get the 'So-n-So won E3..' I guess it creates good debates though.

Whatever you do, don't go on youtube and mention this stuff on ELPRESADOR or WCIPchampl00 or any of "those" types.  They'll curse your entire family.

What´s "winning" E3 all about?....I don´t see any practical benefits for me because of who the media thinks "won" E3...I never understood this "winning" E3 talk from a simple gamer/customer perspective...though I can see why it´s important for bragging rights for the suits at Sony/MS/Nintendo and their fanboys.

I agree with this... Microsoft was pretty solidly out front. Nintendo improved drastically over last year, but I think Sony eeked out a second place, even with the blow of all their stuff being "yeah, I knew about that" territory and their "megaton" gong multiplat.